Our story

The Team Behind The Benincasa Group

Law firm with a personal touch, right here in Water Mill.

Who we are

A Water Mill Name You Can Trust

The Benincasa Group is a Water Mill law firm built on a simple idea: East End clients deserve attorneys who are reachable, straightforward, and genuinely invested in the outcome.

From real estate closings and estate plans to business formation and municipal matters, we bring big-firm thoroughness with small-firm attention. Every client gets honest advice, transparent fees, and a lawyer who picks up the phone.

The Benincasa Group — Water Mill

Reachable counsel

Your attorney answers — 48-hour response promise, usually faster.

Plain-English advice

No legalese fog. You'll understand every option and every fee.

East End roots

We know the towns, the boards, and the local way deals get done.

0
client matters handled
0
years of combined experience
0
-hour response promise
0
core practice areas

* Illustrative figures shown for demonstration.

Kind words

What Water Mill Says About Us

★★★★★
“Handled our home purchase flawlessly — caught issues in the contract our last attorney missed. Responsive every single step.”
— Homebuyer, Water Mill
★★★★★
“Finally, a lawyer who explains things in plain English and actually calls back. Our wills and trusts are done right.”
— Client, Southampton
★★★★★
“The Benincasa Group set up my LLC and contracts quickly and affordably. My go-to for business matters.”
— Business Owner, Bridgehampton

Ready When You Are

One call is all it takes. Reach The Benincasa Group today — we'll take it from there.

📞 Call 631-500-9595